When Magicians Make Mistakes
There are four kinds of mistakes a magician can make.
1. The magician accidentally makes a noticeable mistake.
For example, he drops a palmed object—a coin, ball, or playing card.
This is always embarrassing for the sleight-of-hand artist. An object secretly concealed in the magician’s hand suddenly falls onto the table or the floor in full view of the audience. You, the performer, are not only shocked and surprised—you’re embarrassed! What do you do or say at that moment?
If you have performed enough shows, this has happened to you at least once. In my magic, I like to have a very light touch when performing sleights, as well as a casual air about my performance, so occasionally dropping things like coins happens—well, let’s just say, more than once.
The best response is usually to use humor to downplay the disaster or simply ad-lib your way through the error. Most of the time, you can smooth over the mistake and make it look as though it was supposed to happen.
The more experience you have, the better prepared you become for these mishaps. But even the seasoned professional will eventually encounter something that has never happened before—and probably never will again.
So enjoy the challenge!
Alexander Herrmann, the great 19th-century French conjurer, was especially skilled at ad-libbing his way out of a mishap.
During one stage performance, Herrmann was down in the audience performing his appearing-water-bowl trick. Three large bowls filled with water and goldfish were produced from beneath a spectator’s shawl. While producing one of the bowls, the round, rubber-like cover used to secretly secure the water inside the bowl slipped from Herrmann’s grip and fell to the floor with a slosh.
Without missing a beat, Herrmann picked up the wet, black rubber cover, placed it on his head, and said:
“Ah, my beret. I always wear it when I perform zis treek!”
The audience laughed, and the disaster became part of the entertainment.
2. The magician pretends he made a mistake.
Performers sometimes refer to this as “The Magician in Trouble.”
To pull it off successfully, some acting ability is required. The magician deliberately creates tension by making the audience believe something has gone wrong. His apparent mistake is then quickly corrected by magic.
At that point, most audiences realize that the mistake was part of the act all along, and they enjoy the deception.
Most professional magicians use this technique sparingly. Unless, of course, you have a comical persona and screwing things up is what you do!
3. The magician thinks he made a mistake, not realizing it’s actually a miracle.
Nothing is more startling to a magician than when real magic happens to them. It is in these rare moments that the seasoned magician instantly becomes a simple layman. Good magicians love these moments… unfortunately, they don’t come along very often.
It was 1978, and I was performing close-up magic for a group of magicians. The effect I was doing was a Dice Stacking routine.
For those not familiar with Dice Stacking, it involves four casino-style dice and a leather dice cup. The four dice lie in a row on a smooth table surface. The dice cup is moved back and forth along the table on its edge in a fluid figure-eight pattern. Each time the cup passes a die, that die is scooped up into the cup. When all four dice are gathered into the cup, the cup is brought to a standstill. When the cup is lifted, all four dice are seen to be stacked in a vertical row, one on top of the other.
In my routine, I perform various stacks and un-stacks of the dice, each one building and getting a little more challenging. In one stack, I demonstrate how to stack all four dice in a single, quick cup move. I move the cup quickly across the table, gathering all four dice in one sweep. When the cup is lifted, the four dice are vertically stacked.
Having performed dice stacking for a long time, I knew the “sound and feel” of a successful stack.
When the cup came to a standstill, this stack did not feel right.
But I slowly lifted the cup anyway.
The audience began to shout and scream. At first, I did not know what I was seeing.
The dice had stacked in a totally impossible way. One die on the bottom, two dice side by side in the middle, and one on top, impossibly balanced, creating a cross or plus design.
It took me a moment to realize the impossibility of what had just happened. I wanted to shout out in amazement along with my audience.
But fortunately, I kept my cool and acted like this was what I intended to do all along.
I knew I did not have a trick in my repertoire that could top what I had just done, so I slowly put my props away, thanked the group for being such a good audience, and went on to the next table.
I still associate with many of the magicians present at that performance, and to this day they are convinced I can do that impossible stack any time I want.
4. The magician makes a mistake but is unaware of it.
This is the nightmare scenario for magicians.
You often don’t realize you are in trouble until you are well into the trick. With skill and experience, you may be able to correct the problem—or at least make it look as though the problem was part of the effect.
Sometimes, however, the only way out is to put the effect down, smile, and say:
“I would like to show you something different.”
Mistakes become especially perilous when a trick employs a dangerous element. Part of the dramatic appeal of such an effect is the knowledge that if something goes wrong, the magician could be seriously injured—or even killed.
Harry Houdini’s act was full of stunts like this.
Even when magicians take every precaution when performing dangerous effects, things can still go wrong. It is usually a matter of “when,” not “if.”
The extreme example is the Bullet Catch.
A signed or otherwise marked bullet is apparently fired from a gun at the magician, who then catches it on a plate held in front of his chest—or even in his teeth.
In such a lethal-looking magical effect, the magician may be completely unaware that anything has gone wrong until he is lying injured on the stage.
Several magicians have died in connection with attempts to perform the bullet catch. Perhaps the most famous case was that of Chung Ling Soo.
On March 23, 1918, during a performance in London, Chung Ling Soo attempted his version of the bullet catch. One of the guns discharged a live bullet, striking him in the chest.
Soo had famously performed for years while maintaining the stage persona of a Chinese magician who never spoke publicly. But after being shot, he reportedly broke character and said:
“Oh my God. Something’s happened. Lower the curtain.”
He died the following day.
There was another remarkable twist to the story: Chung Ling Soo was not Chinese at all. He was actually an American-born magician named William Ellsworth Robinson, who had created the elaborate Chinese stage persona as part of his act.
For a magician, there may be no more sobering reminder that sometimes a mistake isn’t part of the show.
Sometimes, it is the show.
Leave a Reply